Broadway has a thing for Yonkers. One of its biggest musicals is set here. So is a play that won the Pulitzer Prize. But the story starts with a flop that had Yonkers right in the title.
The Flop
In 1938, Thornton Wilder was on a roll. He had just won the Pulitzer Prize for Our Town. His next play was a comedy called The Merchant of Yonkers. It followed Horace Vandergelder, a rich and grumpy Yonkers store owner who wants a wife. Wilder based it on an 1842 Viennese comedy by Johann Nestroy.
The show opened on Broadway on December 28, 1938, with the famous director Max Reinhardt in charge. It closed after just 39 performances.
The Fix
Wilder did not give up on it. He rewrote the play and gave the spotlight to Dolly Levi, the matchmaker Vandergelder hires to find him a wife. Spoiler: she decides to marry him herself. He called the new version The Matchmaker. It opened at the Edinburgh Festival in Scotland in 1954. Then it came to Broadway in December 1955 with Ruth Gordon as Dolly. This time it ran 486 performances, and director Tyrone Guthrie won a Tony. Hollywood filmed The Matchmaker in 1958, with Shirley Booth as Dolly.
Hello, Dolly!
Next came the music. Hello, Dolly! opened at the St. James Theatre on January 16, 1964, with Carol Channing as Dolly. It ran 2,844 performances. It also won 10 Tony Awards, including Best Musical. No show won more in one year until 2001, when Mel Brooks' The Producers won 12. The title song became a hit on its own, too. Louis Armstrong's recording reached No. 1 in May 1964 and knocked The Beatles out of the top spot.
The Movie's Yonkers Is in Garrison
Hollywood made the movie in 1969, with Barbra Streisand as Dolly and Walter Matthau as Vandergelder. Louis Armstrong showed up to sing the title song with her. But the film did not shoot its Yonkers scenes in Yonkers. The crew went up the Hudson to Garrison Landing in Putnam County. In 1968 they repainted buildings, built a gazebo near the water and added a cupola to the little train station. That old station house is now home to the Depot Theatre.
Broadway Comes Back to Yonkers
In 1991, Neil Simon brought Yonkers back to Broadway. Fun fact: years earlier, Simon wrote jokes for Sid Caesar, who was born in Yonkers. Lost in Yonkers opened at the Richard Rodgers Theatre on February 21, 1991. It is set in 1942, during World War II. Two teenage brothers, Jay and Arty, are sent to live with their strict grandmother and their Aunt Bella. Grandma runs Kurnitz's Kandy Store, and the family lives upstairs.
The Pulitzer
Lost in Yonkers won the 1991 Pulitzer Prize for Drama. It was the first Neil Simon play to win one, after decades of hits. It also won the Tony Award for Best Play, plus Tonys for Mercedes Ruehl and Irene Worth. The show ran 780 performances.
So the next time someone tells you nothing happens in Yonkers, remind them that Broadway set two classics here. One started as a 39-show flop. The other won a Pulitzer.
Follow @TheYonkersCollective for more Yonkers stories, and read Not Upstate at thenineonefour.com.
Want more stories like this?
Sign up free for the Not Upstate Digital Magazine. It's all about the people, places and culture of Westchester and the Hudson Valley.
