Get stories like this free, every other week.

Mel Brooks, Neil Simon and Carl Reiner all wrote comedy for the same man. That man learned his best trick clearing tables in Yonkers. His name was Sid Caesar, and his comedy school was his father's diner.

Born in Yonkers

Isaac Sidney Caesar was born in Yonkers on September 8, 1922. He graduated from Yonkers High. His parents, Max and Ida, ran a lunch counter that never closed. In a 2005 interview for UCLA, Sid explained how. His brother Dave worked from six at night to six in the morning. His brother Abe took over at six and worked until six at night. Sid remembered the prices, too. Three eggs any style, toast, butter and coffee cost fifteen cents.

Every Table Had Its Own Language

Yonkers was a factory town full of immigrants, and they ate at the Caesars' counter. Each group sat together. Sid wrote in his 2003 memoir, Caesar's Hours, that he heard Italian, Russian, Polish, Hungarian, French, Spanish, Lithuanian and even Bulgarian. In a 1992 Boston Globe interview he called it "a mad mix of Italian, Russian, and Polish dialects."

He did not learn those languages. He learned how they sounded.

Fake Italian at the Italian Table

Sid was so young that his head barely reached the top of the table. He tried his first fake Italian on a table of Italian customers. At first they thought he was one of their own. Then they figured out it was gibberish, and they loved it. They sent him to the Polish table to do it again. Soon the whole room was laughing.

That trick has a name: double-talk. It means made-up words that sound like a real language. People were shocked to learn he couldn't speak any of those languages.

The Saxophone Nobody Claimed

The diner gave Sid his music, too. When he was a boy, someone left a saxophone behind at his father's place. Nobody ever came back for it, so it became his. By 14 he was playing saxophone at summer resorts in the Catskills. Between sets, he started trying out comedy bits.

Live on TV

After the Coast Guard, Sid made the jump to television. Your Show of Shows started on NBC on February 25, 1950. It ran live for 90 minutes on Saturday nights until June 1954. Sid and his cast spoofed foreign movies in fake French, German and Italian. His fake Russian was so good that General Dwight D. Eisenhower asked him where he learned it.

The Writers' Room

The jokes came from one of the most famous writers' rooms in TV history. Mel Brooks wrote for Sid. So did Neil Simon, Larry Gelbart, Mel Tolkin and Lucille Kallen. Gelbart went on to develop M*A*S*H for television. Carl Reiner, who also performed on the show, later built The Dick Van Dyke Show around life as a TV comedy writer. Neil Simon turned the room into a 1993 Broadway play, Laughter on the 23rd Floor.

Not bad for a kid who started out clearing tables at a Yonkers lunch counter.

Follow @TheYonkersCollective for more Yonkers stories, and read Not Upstate at thenineonefour.com.

Want more stories like this?

Sign up free for the Not Upstate Digital Magazine. It's all about the people, places and culture of Westchester and the Hudson Valley.

Liked this one? Get the free Not Upstate magazine.

Recommended for you

View all
caret-right